How to Make a Business Game: Goals, Mechanics and Scoring

business game designentrepreneurship educationgamificationserious gamesgamepreneurship

TL;DR

To make a business game that people learn from, start with one decision you want players to practise, turn it into a rule with a real trade-off, give fast feedback, score the behaviour you want to see in real life, and finish every session with a debrief. Research on simulation games backs this order: games built on active decisions taught more than lectures, games taught mostly through passive content didn't, and results were best when a debrief linked the game to real work. Prototype on paper, playtest five times with real players, and only then build anything digital.

quote image

See a full business game in action

Fe/male Switch is a startup game for women founders, built on our gamepreneurship method: real quests, a team, a mentor, an investor and an AI co-founder.

Start the game today

What is a business game, and how does it differ from gamification?

I'm Violetta Bonenkamp, founder of Fe/male Switch, and the creator of "gamepreneurship", the method behind our startup game for women. Before you design anything, separate two things people mix up all the time.

  • A business game is a complete game where players run a company, or part of one, and face the consequences of their choices. Startup Company on PC, the card game Startups and our own Fe/male Switch are business games.
  • Gamification is the use of game design elements in non-game contexts. That definition comes from Sebastian Deterding and colleagues in their 2011 paper on defining gamification. Points for finished sales calls, badges in an employee course and a leaderboard for referrals are gamification.

When people search "turn business into a game", they want gamification. When they search "business game design", they want a game. This guide covers both, with most of the space on the game.

Want to see the main families of existing startup games first? Read our hub on the start up game.

What makes a business game teach anything?

The clearest evidence is Traci Sitzmann's meta-analysis of 65 studies with 6,476 trainees, published in Personnel Psychology. Trainees who learned with computer-based simulation games scored 11% higher on factual knowledge, 14% higher on skill-based knowledge and 9% higher on retention than comparison groups. Her design lessons are the best checklist I know:

  1. Make players act. About 16% of the games in the review delivered most of their content passively, and those did no better than lectures, discussions or assignments.
  2. Let them play again. Learning was strongest when trainees could return to the game as many times as they wanted.
  3. Embed the game and debrief it. Games worked best as part of a wider programme, with a session afterwards that connects the game to real work.
  4. Don't count on decoration. Entertainment features, such as playing a character in a fantasy world, did not change how much people learned.

Point 4 matters for your budget. Spend on decisions and feedback, then on graphics.

How do you design a business game, step by step?

The business game design loop: learning goal, decision and trade-off, mechanic and scoring, paper prototype, playtest, debrief

Here is the process I use, from blank page to a game you can run in a classroom or a workshop.

1. Write one learning goal as a decision

"Understand cash flow" is too vague to design. "Decide when to hire your first employee without running out of cash" is a goal you can build a rule around. Pick one decision per game, or per level.

2. Define players, setting and time

Who plays (students, new managers, women founders), where (classroom, online, at home), for how long (30 minutes, a full day, four weeks) and in what group size. A 20-minute card game and a four-week online game need different rules.

3. Pick a format

FormatGood forCost to buildExample
Card or board gameClassrooms, workshops, 3 to 7 playersLowStartups by Oink Games, Acquire
Spreadsheet simulationFinance, pricing, unit costsLowYour own model with turns
Role-play with casesNegotiation, pitching, salesLowPlayers act as founder, investor, customer
Digital simulationComplex systems, many runsHighStartup Company, Capitalism Lab
Online game with real tasksFounders building a real companyMedium to highFe/male Switch

4. Turn the decision into mechanics

Use the MDA framework by Robin Hunicke, Marc LeBlanc and Robert Zubek, taught at the Game Developers Conference from 2001 to 2004 and written up in their 2004 MDA paper. Mechanics are the rules and components. Dynamics are the behaviour that appears when players use those rules against each other over time. Aesthetics are the feelings players get, such as challenge or fellowship. Designers build from mechanics up; players experience the game from feelings down. So write the feeling you want ("pressure to choose between two good options") and test whether your rules produce it.

5. Build the economy and the scoring

Decide what players earn, spend and lose: cash, time, reputation, customers. Then decide how they win (more on scoring below).

6. Add feedback and a little chance

Players need to see the result of a decision quickly, and why it happened. Add enough chance (a market event card, a random customer) that luck can hurt you, and never so much that skill stops mattering.

7. Prototype on paper

Index cards, a printed board, coins from another game. You should be able to change a rule in one minute.

8. Playtest, change one rule, playtest again

See the playtesting section below.

9. Write the debrief before the first real session

Three to five questions that link game moments to real decisions. Without them you have a fun afternoon and little learning.

Which mechanics fit which business lesson?

Business lessonMechanicWhere you can see it
Cash flow and burn rateIncome and costs every turn; game over at zeroFe/male Switch: keep your burn rate positive, earn more than you spend
Majority stakes and investingOnly the largest holder gets paidStartups by Oink Games
Mergers and exitsCompanies merge; holders get bonusesAcquire by Sid Sackson
Capacity planningDemand grows faster than your serversStartup Company
Hiring and team fitStaff with skills, salaries and moraleSoftware Inc.
BottlenecksProduction lines with one slowest stepProduction Line, Good Company
Pitching and negotiationRole cards for founder, mentor, investorFe/male Switch roles, a pitch round in class
Learning on the jobA short module sits next to every hard taskFe/male Switch Skill Lab next to the game quests

Pick one or two lessons per game. Every extra mechanic adds rules to explain and less time to play. For a closer look at the PC games in this table, read our startup simulator PC guide.

How do you score a business game?

Scoring is where most business games go wrong: they reward profit only, so players learn to chase the number and skip the thinking. Score the behaviour you want in real life.

An example scoring sheet (our own suggestion for a startup workshop):

Points forWhy
Cash left at the endSurvival matters
Customer interviews loggedEvidence before building
Assumptions tested and droppedLearning from a "no"
A pitch the "investor" players backCommunication
Team members who stayed all gameLeadership

Two rules I hold to: show the score during the game, so players can change course, and reward learning moves such as killing a weak idea early. In Fe/male Switch every Skill Lab module and every won quest becomes a micro-credential on a live certificate, so effort leaves a visible trace beyond the leaderboard.

How do you playtest a business game?

  1. Play it alone first with all hands open. Fix rules that don't work before anyone else sees them.
  2. Run five sessions with real players from your target group, and keep the same facilitator.
  3. Stay silent and take notes. Write down every question players ask; each one is a rule that needs clearer wording.
  4. Time each phase. If setup takes longer than playing, cut setup.
  5. Change one rule between sessions, so you know what caused the difference.
  6. Ask three questions at the end: what decision was hardest, what would you do differently, and what would that look like in a real company?

Five sessions is our rule of thumb, an estimate from our own pilots. Fe/male Switch went through two pilots, the second one four weeks long, and players reported bugs and suggested features during it.

Screenshot of femaleswitch.com, a finished startup game for women entrepreneurs

Where does gamepreneurship fit in?

Gamepreneurship is my name for learning entrepreneurship by playing a startup game whose tasks produce real work. Our method combines the "play to learn" foundation of serious games with the "play to earn" mechanics of blockchain games. In Fe/male Switch a quest asks for a real pitch deck; a mentor joins your team through an NDA; an investor joins through a convertible loan agreement.

For teachers and facilitators, our resource site Gamepreneurship breaks an entrepreneurship game session into four moves: define the job, pick the constraint (time, money or evidence), give feedback, and debrief to choose the next test. It also says something I want every designer to remember: a game builds decision skills, and it can't validate a startup idea on its own. Real customers do that.

If your students need project ideas to play with, our project ideas for business students list gives them realistic starting points.

How do you turn your business into a game?

For founders who want to gamify their own company (sales, customer education, team learning), use the same rules on a smaller scale:

  • Pick one behaviour you want more of, such as completed product tutorials or referrals.
  • Give fast, visible feedback: progress bars, levels, a weekly highlight.
  • Reward the real outcome, then the activity. Points for "referred friend became a customer" teach more than points for "shared a link".
  • Test with ten people before you roll it out.

FAQ

How do you make a business game?

Choose one decision players should practise, pick a format (cards, spreadsheet, role-play or digital), turn the decision into rules with a trade-off, design the economy and scoring, prototype on paper, playtest five times and finish every session with a debrief.

What is business game design?

It is the process of turning a business situation into rules, resources and goals so that players face real trade-offs and see the results of their choices. Frameworks such as MDA (mechanics, dynamics, aesthetics) help you check that your rules create the experience you want.

What is the difference between a business game and gamification?

A business game is a complete game in which players run a company. Gamification adds game elements, such as points, levels and leaderboards, to a non-game activity like a sales process or an online course.

How do you write a business game essay or reflection?

Describe the situation in the game, the decision you made and why, what happened, and what you would change. Then link it to a real business: name the real-world version of your decision and what evidence you would need before making it. These are the same questions a good debrief asks.

Can a business game help someone start a real company?

Yes, for skills and confidence: research shows simulation games beat comparison groups on knowledge and retention when play is active and followed by a debrief. The real test of an idea still happens with real customers, which is why our startup game for women sends players to them.

What should you do next?

Write your learning goal as one decision, sketch a paper version this week and run your first playtest with five people. Use the scoring table above as a starting point and keep a notebook of every question players ask. If you want to play a finished business game before you design your own, try Fe/male Switch, the startup game for women, and note which mechanics you would borrow.

About the Authors

Violetta Bonenkamp, also known as Mean CEO, is the founder of Fe/male Switch, a startup game for women founders, and co-founder of CADChain. She holds an MBA and four other higher education degrees, has more than 20 years of work experience across several countries, and was named one of the top 100 women founders in Europe by EU-Startups in 2022. Dirk-Jan Bonenkamp, co-founder and Chief Legal Officer of CADChain, brings a background in law, intellectual property, tax and finance, and writes about the legal and money side of starting a company.